How to choose an SEO company: the questions you're allowed to ask
Short answer
Pick the company that puts everything in your name, shows you work you can check yourself, and tells you in writing what it does each month. Ask who owns your domain and Search Console, how they handle schema, listings, redirects and speed, and what their reports show. If they guarantee rankings, walk away.
Most owners I talk to have paid a marketing agency at some point, and when I ask what they got for the money, they can’t tell me. That isn’t on them. Nobody told them which questions they were allowed to ask.
Part of why we started BotFanatics is that I audited marketing agencies and didn’t like what I found. Schema missing or done wrong. Nobody looking at PageSpeed. Blogs nobody updated, pages that didn’t link to each other, no backlink cleanup. And when I got technical on a call, the agency owner had to go find their technical guy.
This is for owners of any kind of business. We’ve worked with med spas in Miami and Southlake, a criminal defense law firm, a physician mortgage program, a scalp micropigmentation studio, and plumbing, HVAC, roofing and garage door companies.
You don’t need to understand SEO to ask the questions below. You need to know what a good answer sounds like, and how to check it yourself once they’ve said it.
Warm up: good answer or red flag?
These are the kinds of lines you hear on a sales call. Tap what you think each one is.
0 of 7 answered
- "We guarantee you a top spot on Google within 30 days."Google’s own guide to hiring an SEO says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking, and if someone does, find someone else.
- "Keep Search Console in your name and add us as a user."Your history stays with you if you ever leave. This is how it should be set up.
- "We’ll register the domain under our account so you don’t have to deal with it."Convenient right up until you want to leave. The domain should be registered to you.
- "Here’s a site we built last month. Run Google’s speed test on it yourself."Proof you can check in a minute beats a screenshot in a slide deck.
- "SEO is complicated. We’ll send a monthly report and you let us handle it."A report you can’t check against your own data is just a story. Ask what changed and where you can see it.
- "Before we move your site, we’ll list every old URL and where it goes, then check each one after launch."That list is how a new site keeps the rankings the old one earned.
- "We have a special relationship with Google."Google lists this exact claim as a warning sign. Nobody gets special treatment.
Start with what you own
Before strategy, before keywords, find out whose name is on everything. Owners almost never know they can ask this, and it hurts the most when you find out late. If the agency holds your domain or your Google accounts, leaving them means starting over without your history.
Each of these takes about a minute to check. Tick the ones that are true today.
Google’s advice goes a step further. If someone only wants to audit your site, give them read access in Search Console, not ownership.
Questions to ask an SEO company before you sign
These separate the people who do the work from the people who resell it. For each one, here’s what a good answer sounds like.
“Will you set up schema markup? Which types?”
Schema is code on your pages that tells Google and AI tools, in their own format, your business name, address, hours, services and reviews. A good answer names the types: LocalBusiness (or the specific kind, like Dentist, MedicalSpa, LegalService or Plumber), Service, FAQPage. “Yes, we handle that” is not an answer. You can check what you have now by pasting any page into Google’s Rich Results Test.
“Will you fix my NAP everywhere, or just on the site?”
NAP means name, address and phone. Google compares them across your website, your Google Business Profile, Bing, Apple Maps, Yelp and the directories. When they disagree, it gets less sure which business is which. On one med spa’s site we found call buttons on 32 pages showing phone numbers that weren’t theirs, and nobody had noticed. A good answer comes with the list of listings they’ll check.
“I’m on WordPress, Webflow, Squarespace or Wix. What happens when we move?”
Moving platforms is where a lot of rankings get lost. Here’s what should come with you from each one, and the question to ask about it.
- WordPressWhat comes with youPages, posts, images and every old address. WordPress exports most of it.Watch forAsk which plugins do real work (forms, booking, popups) and how each one gets replaced, so nothing breaks quietly.
- WebflowWhat comes with youPages, CMS collections, images and old addresses.Watch forAsk how Google Analytics keeps recording after the move. Webflow loads it its own way, and that part doesn’t come along by itself.
- SquarespaceWhat comes with youOnly part of it exports, so expect pages rebuilt from the live site.Watch forAsk how they’ll prove the rebuilt pages match the old ones.
- WixWhat comes with youNothing exports in full. Pages get rebuilt from what’s live.Watch forAsk for the before and after list of pages, so you can see nothing went missing.
“How do you handle redirects?”
Every page on your old site has an address Google and other websites already know. When that address changes, a redirect sends them to the new one. Skip it and those links hit an error page, and the rankings they carried go with them. Listen for “every old URL mapped, then checked after launch.” On one move we checked 284 old addresses one by one. Ask to see the list.
“What will my mobile PageSpeed score be? Show me one you built.”
Don’t accept a screenshot. Paste one of their past sites in here and run Google’s own test, then run yours.
For comparison, here are two sites before and after we rebuilt them.
Mobile PageSpeed score, before and after our rebuild
“What will your reports show, and can I check them myself?”
A report only means something if you can check it against data the agency doesn’t control.
- "Traffic is up," without saying from where
- Rankings with no dates and no starting point
- "Optimized 14 pages," with no list of which ones
- A PDF once a month that nobody explains
- Indexed pages, the same number you see in your own Search Console
- Rankings with the date checked and where you started
- Every page changed, with a link to it
- A page you can open any time, not once a month
A quick test: every number in the report should say where it came from and what dates it covers. If one doesn’t, ask.
“Who actually writes the content, and does a person check it?”
Anyone can put out dozens of generic AI posts a month now, and Google has no reason to keep them. A good answer: the pages are written from an interview with you, in your words, with your real prices, process and numbers, and a person reads every page before it goes up, sources included. Ask to see a page they wrote for another client and look for anything on it a competitor couldn’t copy. The red flag is a big monthly post count and nobody asking you a single question.
“What does your AI visibility tracking actually show?”
Lots of agencies sell AI visibility now. Ask to see the tracking. It should show the exact questions being asked, which AI tools get asked (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Google’s AI answers), how often, whether you were named and where in the list, and which websites the AI used as its sources. Here are three rows from one week of ours for a plumbing client.
Did ChatGPT name our plumber? Three of the seven questions we track
| Question | Nov 4 | Nov 5 | Nov 6 | Nov 7 | Nov 8 | Nov 9 | Nov 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| best plumber in McKinney TX | named 1st | named 1st | named 1st | not named | named 1st | named 1st | named 1st |
| tankless water heater repair McKinney TX | named 1st | named 1st | named 1st | named 1st | named 1st | named 1st | named 1st |
| water heater replacement Plano TX | not named | not named | not named | not named | not named | not named | not named |
The last row is the useful one. A question where you never get named points at the page that’s missing, and an agency should be able to tell you what they’ll do about rows like that. The full week, and what we did about Plano, is in another post. For a med spa we work with in Miami, the same kind of work got them named first in Google’s AI Overview for “best place for lipo shots in Miami.”
You can also just ask the AI yourself, right now. Type what you do and where.
Didn't see your name? If you're paying for AI visibility and a competitor gets named instead, ask your agency why.
Have us run the full checkRuns in your browser. We don't see what you type.
“Do you work with anyone else in my industry, in my area?”
A home services owner in Colorado told me the thing he liked most about a past agency’s pitch was that they wouldn’t take on a competitor in his service area. Whatever you do, it’s a fair thing to ask. You’re paying them to beat the business down the street, so find out whether the business down the street pays them too. I’m honestly not sure it should be a dealbreaker every time, since an agency that knows your industry well has probably worked for someone like you. But you should know the answer before you sign, not after.
“Who actually does the work?”
At a lot of agencies, the person who sold you isn’t the person touching your site, and sometimes nobody in the room could explain the work if you asked. Ask who will make the changes, and whether you can talk to that person directly.
“Can I talk to one of your current clients?”
Testimonials on their site don’t count here. You want a person you can call, and a good agency will connect you with one, with that client’s OK. Ask them two things: what changed after they signed, and how fast the agency gets back to them. If the agency can’t name anyone, ask why.
“What happens if I cancel?”
Ask how much notice you have to give, and get it in writing before you sign. Then ask what you keep: the content they wrote, the site files, and every account on the checklist above. You want to hear “all of it.” Some agencies keep the site or the pages they wrote when you leave, and that’s better to find out now.
Bring these questions to the call
Who owns my domain, hosting, Search Console, Google Analytics and Google Business Profile?
Which schema types will you set up on my site?
Will you fix my name, address and phone on every listing, or only on the site?
If we change platforms, what happens to my pages and old URLs?
Can I see the redirect list after launch?
What's the mobile PageSpeed score on a site you built recently?
What will your reports show, and can I check every number myself?
Who writes the content, and does a person check it?
What does your AI visibility tracking show, and how often is it checked?
Do you work with anyone else in my industry, in my area?
Who actually makes the changes on my site?
Can I talk to one of your current clients?
What happens if I cancel, and what do I keep?Red flags when hiring an SEO agency
- Guaranteed rankings, or number one by a date
- Your domain, hosting or Google accounts in their name
- A long contract with no list of what you get each month
- Reports you can’t check against your own Search Console
- A "special relationship" with Google
- They can’t tell you what changed last month
- A plan with dates for the work, and no promises about Google’s side
- Everything in your name, with the agency added as a user
- What you get each month in writing, and what you keep if you leave
- Numbers that match what you see when you log in yourself
- Plain answers when you ask what something means
- A list of last month’s changes, with links
Already paying an agency? We'll look at your site and tell you what's been done.
Get a second opinionHow to audit the marketing agency you already have
You don’t need to fire anyone to find out. Give yourself half an hour with your own logins and go in this order.
A half-hour audit of your current agency
- Step 1Your loginsCan you get into the domain, Search Console, Analytics and your Google profile on your own?Red flag: you have to ask the agency for access to your own accounts.
- Step 2Search ConsoleOpen the Pages report. How many pages are indexed, and is the number going up?Red flag: a pile of "crawled, currently not indexed" pages nobody has mentioned.
- Step 3Last monthAsk for the list of changes. Open each page and paste one into the Rich Results Test.Red flag: no list, or pages that look the same as last year.
- Step 4AI answersAsk ChatGPT who the best [what you do] is in your town.Red flag: they sell AI visibility and can’t show you any tracking.
If step two confuses you, our SEO and Google Maps page explains the difference between crawled and indexed with a health inspector, and it’s the clearest way I’ve found to put it.
Gaps don’t automatically mean your agency is bad. Ask about them first. Some agencies have a good reason and will show you, and some go quiet.
Choosing a web designer is the same test
A website build is usually where the ownership problems start, because whoever builds the site tends to set up the domain and the hosting too. Our websites page has a nine-question checklist for choosing a web designer that you can tick through on the call.
You can ask us every one of these too.
Questions
Can an SEO company guarantee first page rankings?
No. Google's own guide to hiring an SEO says no one can guarantee a number one ranking, and tells you to find someone else if they do. What a good company can promise is the work itself, which pages and fixes, and by when.
How do I choose a digital marketing agency for a local business?
Use the same test as for an SEO company. Everything stays in your name, you get a written list of what you get each month, the reports match your own Search Console and Google Business Profile, and someone picks up when you call. Also ask whether they already work for a competitor in your area.
What questions should I ask a web designer?
Who will own the domain, hosting and files. Whether every service you sell gets its own page. What the mobile PageSpeed score will be, on a site they already built. How old URLs get redirected. Whether schema markup is included. Our websites page has a nine-question checklist you can tick through on the call.
Who should own my domain and my Google accounts?
You. The domain, hosting, Search Console, Google Analytics and your Google Business Profile should all be in your name, with the agency added as a user. Then leaving never costs you your history.
How do I know if my SEO company is doing anything?
Ask for the list of what they changed last month, then check it. Open the pages, paste one into Google's Rich Results Test, and look at the Pages report in your own Search Console. If you can't find the work, ask them to show you.
How long should an SEO contract be?
There's no standard length. What matters more is what you get each month, in writing, and what you keep if you leave. A long contract with no list of deliverables is the one to avoid.