How to rank in ChatGPT when customers ask for a business like yours
Short answer
ChatGPT names the local businesses it can find the most about. Let its search crawler into your site, make sure Google keeps your pages, give every service its own page, and make every listing and review tell the same story. Then check what it says every week.
Type “best plumber in McKinney TX” into ChatGPT. We ask it that every day for a plumbing client of ours, along with six other questions their customers ask. Here’s one week.
Did ChatGPT name our plumber? Seven questions, every day for a week
Each row is a question a customer might type. Each square is one day: did ChatGPT's answer name them, and where in the list?
| What we asked ChatGPT | Nov 4 | Nov 5 | Nov 6 | Nov 7 | Nov 8 | Nov 9 | Nov 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| best plumber in McKinney TX | 1st | 1st | 1st | no | 1st | 1st | 1st |
| who does slab leak repair in McKinney TX | 1st | 1st | 1st | 2nd | 1st | 1st | 2nd |
| plumber in McKinney with upfront pricing | 1st | 1st | 1st | 1st | no | 1st | 1st |
| tankless water heater repair McKinney TX | 1st | 1st | 1st | 1st | 1st | 1st | 1st |
| family owned plumbing company in Collin County | 1st | 1st | 1st | 1st | 1st | 2nd | 1st |
| plumbing maintenance membership plan McKinney TX | 1st | 1st | no | 1st | 1st | 1st | 1st |
| water heater replacement Plano TXnever named | no | no | no | no | no | no | no |
First in almost every answer. On November 7, for the main question, they weren’t in the answer at all, and I can’t tell you why. Nobody controls what ChatGPT says, us included.
Then look at the last row. “Water heater replacement Plano TX”: not once in seven days. Hold onto that one.
Here’s what one of those answers looked like. The tracker saves ChatGPT’s full reply every day, sources included. I took out the other plumbers’ names.
The November 10 answer to "best plumber in McKinney TX"
Top 5 plumbers in McKinney, TX
- Listed as open 24 hours.
- Family-owned local plumbing company. B
- Phone number listed.
Independent directory reports 5.0 stars and 1,088 Google reviews. C
Directory listing reports 5.0 stars and 326 Google reviews.
4.9 stars, 55 reviews in the business listing.
Plumbers D and E, then a map. Our client shows 4.8 stars on the map. C
"I'd call [our client] first, then [Plumber B] for a second estimate."
- dfwbusinesses.org
- contractorsranked.com
- bestprosintown.com
- expertise.com
- bestprosintown.com
- ANamed first, and recommended. At the end it told the reader to call them first and get a second estimate elsewhere.
- BDescribed by its sources. "Family owned" and "open 24 hours" are how the listings describe them, and ChatGPT used the same words. Gate 3.
- CIt quotes the listings word for word. One rating came from a directory, the other from the map. ChatGPT repeats what your listings say, right or wrong. Gate 4.
- DAll directories and lists. Every link points to a directory or a "best plumbers" page. Gates 3 and 4.
Not one of those five sources is a plumber’s website.
Other clients had weeks like it. The same week, ChatGPT named a roofing client first for “family owned roofing company in the nc triad” and a home services client first for “is there one company that does plumbing, HVAC and electrical in the north Denver suburbs?”, each on six of seven days. A med spa client in Miami came up first in Google’s AI Overview for “best place for lipo shots in Miami.”
Four gates
When I got into SEO, ranking meant the prettiest site, the right headers, a blog and some backlinks. ChatGPT wants something else: the business it can say the most about, for the exact question asked, with the least risk of being wrong. Four things decide that.
Four gates between your business and a ChatGPT answer
- 1Let inCan ChatGPT's search crawler read your site at all?Checked in robots.txt
- 2KeptDid Google and the other search sources keep your pages?Checked in the index
- 3MatchedIs there a page, listing or review about the exact thing being asked?Checked against the question
- 4TrustedDoes everything about you agree, so it's safe to name you?Checked across every source
Gate 1: let it in
Most websites have a small file called robots.txt that tells crawlers what they’re allowed to read. ChatGPT’s search crawler is called OAI-SearchBot, and OpenAI’s own documentation is blunt about it: sites that opt out of it “will not be shown in ChatGPT search answers.”
The plumber's robots.txt, the part that matters here
User-agent: GPTBot
Allow: /
User-agent: OAI-SearchBot
Allow: /
Most owners I talk to have never opened theirs. It lives at yoursite.com/robots.txt, and checking it takes ten seconds.
Gate 2: get kept
Google finding a page and Google keeping it are two different things. The pages it keeps go in its index. The ones it doesn’t, as far as search is concerned, aren’t there.
ChatGPT leans on those indexes. Peec’s September 2026 analysis found it pulls from Google and several other providers on top of its own. A page nobody kept is a page nobody can hand over.
How many of their pages Google actually keeps
Even good sites lose pages. The plumber’s one missing page was gas line repair. Google’s verdict in Search Console: “Discovered, currently not indexed.” It knew the page existed and didn’t think it was worth keeping. Fixing it means putting more on the page that a person would actually want to read.
Gate 3: match the question
This is where most of the work is. ChatGPT can’t name you for a job it can’t find you doing.
What ChatGPT cited when asked about local businesses
That’s the average. The McKinney answer above had none. Your own site is still the one source you fully control, though. So every service gets its own page that says what the job is, where you do it, and answers the questions people ask about it. Reviews do the same job from the outside, if they name the work.
Their five-star reviews, by the job the customer named
You can guess which of their pages was easier to make convincing. “Great service, very friendly” is nice to get, but it tells an AI nothing about whether you fix water heaters or do Botox. You can’t write reviews for your customers. You can ask in a way that makes a useful one likely: “If you have a second, mention what we fixed.”
Gate 4: be the safe answer
The last gate is consistency. You saw it in the McKinney answer: one rating from a directory, another on the map, both printed as fact. ChatGPT repeats what your listings say. So every mismatch, like an old address, the name spelled two ways or hours that don’t match, is a reason for it to pick someone else. Your Google Business Profile, Bing Places, Yelp and the rest should all say the same thing, and the cheapest wins here are usually listings nobody ever claimed. Getting those straight is a big part of our SEO and local search work.
Check it yourself tonight
- Gate 1. Open yoursite.com/robots.txt. If you see “OAI-SearchBot” followed by “Disallow: /”, that’s your problem.
- Gate 2. Search Google for site:yoursite.com and see whether your service pages come up. If you have Search Console, the Pages report tells you exactly which ones Google didn’t keep.
- Gate 3. Ask ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google what a customer would ask, the way they’d ask it. Not your business name. Try “best plumber in [your town]” or “who does [your service] near [your area].” Write down who gets named, then do it again on another day.
- Gate 4. Look yourself up on Google Maps, Bing, Yelp and Apple Maps. Same name, phone and hours everywhere?
If you pay an agency, ask them three things. Is our robots.txt letting ChatGPT in? Which of our pages did Google not keep? Can I see which AI answers name us, whenever I want? That last one is the core of our AI visibility work, and it’s why our clients get a live dashboard instead of a PDF at the end of the month.
Back to Plano
Remember the row with seven empty squares? Our client does water heater replacement in Plano. ChatGPT never once said so.
It told us why. On November 10 it explained its Plano picks in one line: “I’ve prioritized companies that advertise water heater installation and replacement.” All five it named had a Plano address. Our client’s Plano page gave water heater replacement one line. Richardson, the next town over, already had a whole page about water heater repair.
So on November 17 we published a page about water heater replacement in Plano, written for the people asking that exact question.
A monthly report would have averaged that row away. Six questions looked great, and the seventh failed every single day.
We’ll keep asking ChatGPT every day. When that row changes, or doesn’t, this post gets the update.
Questions
Why does ChatGPT recommend my competitor and not me?
Usually because it can find more about them. A page for the exact service, a complete Google profile, reviews that mention the work. All of that is fixable.
Does ChatGPT use Google or Bing?
Both, and more. A September 2026 analysis by Peec found ChatGPT uses its own index plus at least eight outside providers, including Google, Yelp and TripAdvisor, with Bing showing up mostly in Deep Research.
Can my website block ChatGPT by accident?
Yes. OpenAI says sites that block OAI-SearchBot in robots.txt won't be shown in ChatGPT search answers. Open yoursite.com/robots.txt and look for it.
Can I do this myself?
Yes. None of it is secret. It takes time, though, and someone has to keep checking the answers every week.